Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 4 star Colin MacRae denies cheating on Chief Stewardess Daisy Kelliher or his now-girlfriend Brittany Amodeo. During the BDSY season 4 reunion, Daisy deflected from her countless flirtations with Chief Officer Gary King while in a boatmance with Colin by repeatedly returning to Colin hooking up with one of his Parlay Revival crew members in the leadup to dating Daisy. The reunion left it an ambiguous if Colin again hooked up with Brittany while dating Daisy after the charter season in Sardinia, Italy, in 2022. Colin didn’t cheat on Daisy or his now-girlfriend Brittany, he now clarified on Instagram on Wednesday.
“Omg ok listen. I was single going into the season. Didn’t sleep with anyone but Daisy for 6 months from then. There was ZERO overlap between Daisy and the ‘other woman’. None. Daisy and I ended things shortly after the show and THEN I hooked up with the ‘other woman’. I’m getting absolutely harassed for having a girlfriend during the show which is absolute horse [manure]… I’m a lot of things but I’m not a cheater,” Colin wrote in response to an Instagram clip from Queens Of Bravo showing clips from the BDSY season 4 reunion which made it look like he cheated.
“So I turn up to the boat and I find out that he has been sleeping with someone that he works with. So I immediately retreat. I put up all of my walls,” Daisy explained in the explosive two-part reunion.
Colin Didn’t Cheat On Daisy Or Girlfriend Britt, But Went Back And Forth After BDSY Season 4
“Then throughout the year, I permanently [sic] asked about this woman, and I asked why it was different with me and Gary and not with this woman. And he said, ‘the difference is that I’m telling you that there is nothing between me and this woman, that there is no future. Even if you and I break up there’s no future,'” Daisy continued.
However, after Colin broke up with Daisy in December 2022, he started an official relationship with Britt “six to eight weeks” later. According to Colin, he and Daisy took a break after the show finished up filming in late July 2022. He then proceeded to again sleep with Brittany, until him and Daisy started dating again through the latter half of 2022.
“You also slept with her when you and I were trying to be together.” Daisy said later on in the reunion.
So it appears Colin started hooking up with Brit again while Daisy and him went on a break.
“Oh why don’t we do a [bleeping] shoutout to you and your girlfriend. Why don’t we do that!? When you’re out there living with her on a boat? Why don’t we film that?” Daisy said to Colin when he cited her flirting with Gary throughout BDSY season 4.
Earlier on Daisy said finding out about Colin’s tryst with his subordinate of his catamaran crew also led to her kissing deckhand Alex Propson on the first night out.
Daisy ‘Humiliated’ Finding Out Months After Breakup Colin Dating Brit
“So then to find out from my crew members a couple of months after we had broken up, that he was now in a serious relationship with this woman, it was very shocking for me to hear, very hurtful. And the toxicity was always there because the trust was never there,” Daisy said.
“The first time I saw her again was at the Newport boat show. I flew her in from the UK to come see me. That was really good,” he said. “There was a couple of other things that we did. We spent a couple of weeks together in Mexico. I flew to New York to see her,” Colin said about dating Daisy after the show.
Awkwardly, Colin’s now-girlfriend Brittany was also at the boat show held on Sept. 15-18, 2022 in Maryland with the Parlay Revival crew. Colin’s Parlay Revival YouTube channel posted a video of the Newport boat show in January.
Besides the trips Colin recounted, Daisy and him also celebrated his birthday in late October. They even went on a motorcycle date.
Colin, age 37, and Daisy, age 36, first started dating again at the Newport boat show. Four months later Colin broke up with her. Daisy also accused of Colin of shady behavior hitting on her at the end of BDSY seasons 2 and 3, when he was in two separate long-term relationships with ex girlfriends at the time.
Fans now suspect Gary and Daisy are dating while filming BDSY season 5. Sadly, Colin didn’t return as part of the BDSY season 5 cast.