Big Brother 25 viewers aren’t buying that Matt Klotz and Reilly Smedley are actually boyfriend and girlfriend after meeting back at the start of August and getting to know each other for two weeks before she got booted off the show. On the finale night, Reilly again professed feelings for Matt before the vote for the winner of BB 25. However, after the show it looks like Reilly has more interest in winner Jag Bains. Fans suspect Big Brother‘s Matt and Reilly relationship was faked.
“Hi Matty. Long time no see… I just want to tell you that I’ve been rooting for you 24/7. I’m so proud of you. Look at where you are now, day 100. Back at week 2 it wasn’t looking so pretty. So I’m really proud of you and everything you’ve overcome in a house full of whispers. I’m so excited to see you and have that conversation we’ve both been wanting to have. And I did bring a little good luck charm. So, I can’t wait to see you, I miss you,” Reilly gushed to Matt on the finale episode.
She previously sent him an HOH letter a few weeks back also expressing her mutual interest in pursuing a relationship with Matt.
Big Brother‘s Matt And Reilly Relationship Fake According Some Fans
“Look who’s finally up in that HOH suite. I can imagine you’re on cloud nine, and you deserve to soak up every ounce of this feeling. Wear that key around your neck proudly. I want you to know how much I believe in you and that myself, your family, and friends are so proud to see you in there kicking butt. I am cheering you on 24/7. Cute braids by the way. If anyone can do this it’s you. I also want you to know how much I miss you and wish I could be telling you all of this in person at 3 AM on the hammock, eating that weird lemon popcorn you make,” Reilly wrote Matt in his HOH letter.
But a lot of BB 25 fans find the whole thing inauthentic. Since the finale wrapped up filming, fans noticed Reilly’s been sidled up next to winner Jag Bains more than runner-up Matt.
At the BB 25 finale after-party, Reilly and Jag were snapped together a bunch. Over the weekend, while the cast were still in LA, the two also appeared tied at the hip. Although some fans said they’re cleary just good friends since meeting on the show, others were suggesting Reilly was more into Jag than Matt.
Reilly Matt and this fake ass long ass hug #bb25
— fortnite gworl (@welpdamn) November 10, 2023
I can’t believe they gave Matt & Reilly fake non existent relationship but not the actual couple from the show???
— mewlan (@saltmew) November 10, 2023
This episode is so fake, with the fake laughing and hooting and hollering. Reilly/Matt budding romance my ass. She wasn't interested when she left. She trying to get on Amazing Race? get on with the winter season reveal and Jag winning 5-2. Terrible Season #BB25
— Y2Jin99 (@Y2Jin99) November 10, 2023
However, on Sunday, Reilly posted on Instagram her and Matt embracing with the caption: “Finally got this guy out of the have-not room.”
Other fans found photos of Reilly and Matt together on the weekend, too.
— bb25lover (@bb24lover1) November 12, 2023
Also, Matt shared with US Weekly that Reilly told him on the finale that her parents moved to Georgia and are only three hours away from him in Baton Rouge, Lousiana.
Fans Will Have To Wait And See If Matt And Reilly’s Relationship Is Real
In the end, only time will tell if Matt and Reilly are still together after the cameras stopped rolling. But so far the two are appearing to give their showmance relationship a real try in the real world.