On The Millionaire Matchmaker season 4 episode “Cinderella and Moondoggie Walk Into A Bar…” Patti Stanger hit a couple of homeruns in setting up millionaire clients PJ Marks and Cindy Guyer. However, Patti prejudged PJ hard for his beach bum Bahamian lifestyle after selling his wakeboarding business. She also thought he dressed terribly with his old faded t-shirts and surfer’s hair. That said, she did find him endearing enough to set him up with her friend Amy Ballon. So, what happened to PJ Marks and Amy after their romantic wakeboarding and beach date on The Millionaire Matchmaker? And are they still together?
Patti found PJ cleaned up nicely after she had one of her assistants take him to get a tailored suit and a proper haircut. She was afraid he may go after the young woman she included in the mixer as a test, but PJ finally matured after admittedly dating a woman in her mid-twenties recently at the time he was age 42.
“I split my time between the Jersey Shore and the Bahamas, but I consider the Bahamas my home now,” PJ explained on the show. He also got his pilots license in 1989 and spends half the year on the Great Guana Key island.
After the show, PJ was tickled by the overwhelmingly positive response he got from fans and his friends. He wrote a letter published by Bravo explaining how he was the only millionaire client who wasn’t selected by cast, but called production to get himself on the show. PJ was convinced unlike many of Patti’s client, he would come across as likable if he was just himself.
PJ also defended himself from Patti’s attacks that he was old and immature, explaining how he actually is a self-made man.
Millionaire Matchmaker: What Happened To PJ Marks & Amy (Are They Together?)
“I’ve water skied, wake boarded, acted and done stunts professionally. I’ve been surfing all over the world. I’m pretty proficient at skate boarding, wake boarding, wake skating, snow skiing, snow boarding, kite boarding, mountain biking and flying planes, hang gliders, sea planes and sailplanes,” PJ explained. “I’ve partied like a rock star (sometimes with rock stars). I’ve been in a real Hollywood movie, done national TV commercials, I’ve written for magazines, narrated as well as produced wakeboarding instructional videos, done color on ESPN, tested boats, designed boats, started businesses and sold them.”
After the show, PJ continues to live his life just the way he wants.
“I continue to live my dream, spending six months out of the year on an island, living it up with my island friends, pursuing my interest in music, renovating my surf shack, landscaping my yard, growing my own veggies, and catching my own fish, conch, and lobster.”
PJ’s Instagram is private, so not a lot else is known about what he’s been up to. However, he did answer the question on everyone’s mind back in his letter to Bravo, was he still together with Amy?
“Amy is wonderful. We had a great time sharing this experience and we remain friends, but she’s not ‘the one’ for me. Truth is, I did not expect to meet anyone on the show. Actually, I don’t believe that anyone can find love by looking for it. It finds you when you are just being yourself. So that’s what I’m doing.”
Meanwhile, Patti’s good friend Amy ended up finding her partner. The real estate development sales and marketing Floridian’s Facebook page shows she’s happily in a relationship. She also enjoys spending time with her daughter and girl friends.
What PJ Has Been Up To Since Starring On The Millionaire Matchmaker Season 4
PJ Marks’s IMDb reveals he’s become a movie producer, investing in the documentary Movie Money Confidential in 2022.
“After my run as a minor celebrity, I purchased a commercial property in the the West End section of Long Branch, NJ. It’s currently completely rented. In 2014 I invested in the cannabis industry and I’m also Executive Producer on a documentary film called Movie Money Confidential. My other credits were camera operator, drone operator, creative consultant and on screen, talent. I also own points in another film called Burt Reynolds: The Last Interview,” PJ explained on his LinkedIn.